I heard the big lie again this week. This time from my sister-in-law. Now never mind that at 50, she has never been married nor had children (or even custody of children.) While she may be a great babysitter, we repediately run into problems with her because she cannot objectively judge discipline situations with her nieces and nephews. But now, she’s 100% against us homeschooling. She won’t even talk about it.
I find this so funny in a way, yet so tragic. Here’s the facts…
She does not know one child who has been or is being homeschooled.
She knows absolutely nothing about the homeschool process or success stories.
While she knows some things about the school systems around this country, she often defers to her own experience more than 20 years ago.
She has never listened to our plans on how to accomplish homeschooling.
So what’s her beef. The buzz word.
SOCIALIZATION….
My head begins to throb everytime someone like her mentions that word. It means absolutely nothing. Zip. Zero. I ask a purely meaningless question. Since when did we send our kids to school for the socialization side of things? I thought school was about learning? Then I look at our evidenced three children in progress (my stepkids) and I find the following.
1) Kevin – now 23 – not a social animal. Stayed home with his mother and had almost zero contact with other kids until he was 4 years-old. Attended public schools his entire career.
2) Mark – now 19 – socially dependent. Started daycare almost immediately after birth. Attended public schools his entire life.
3) Allie – now 14 – oversocialized. Started daycare almost immediately after birth. Attended public schools for most of her career. Spent one year in private education.
I ask is there such a thing as oversocialization? Do children in today’s world become socially dependent? Don’t get me wrong, I think having friends and social contacts is very important. What I think is more important though is that a child’s life be centered around his family and God. (Well, that’s the Christian side of me. But even if faith isn’t a part of your life, your kids lives should be centered around your family and your values.)
I look at Mark and Allie. Even though dad left when they were 4 and 9, the ball was already in motion for their social lives. I believe, like so many other things in a child’s development, that the Toddler years set the stage for what direction we are going to go. Since both of them were in day care (actually private baby sitters) with many other kids, their whole lives began with those 8-10 hour days being filled with constant social interactions. Their sitters were not formally teaching them. It was not a pre-school environment. School just continued to foster that friend-centered environment, along with a single-mom trying to make her own life easier.
I make these assertations, because then I look at Kevin. Essentially, Kevin was nutured in the home. He is a very smart person and always has been. They put him in preschool at 4 because he hated interacting with other children as he had been kept separate most of his early life. He never gained the social savy that Mark and Allie have. His friends list was always shorter. He often found solace in his own company and in activities like reading and writing – a polar opposite of the other two. He also had a greater family-center than the others.
Is this because of personality differences? Or is this because of the environment?
So back to my original statements. I believe that homeschooling and socialization have not much to do with one another. Schools afford the parent a convenient opportunity to expose their children to a large number of random social contacts their own age. In homeschooling, parents have to look to different means to select social contacts for their children. Isn’t it funny that my sister-in-law would think that we’re going to lock Bump up in a room all day and not let him talk to anyone but us? Is that responsible parenting? If we go to all the trouble to make sure his education is the best, why wouldn’t we go to the limits to make sure he also receives the social contact he needs? That’s right – he needs. What is it that he needs for social contacts? Is it what is defined by the public school systems?
I could go on. One thing that’s painfully obvious to me is that my in-laws as a whole are not willing to look outside the box on this one. Sadly, it will make it much more difficult to share Bump’s successes.
Enought of this rant!!!!!